What the charge means
Mischief under s.430 covers wilful destruction, damage, rendering useless, or obstruction of the lawful use of property. Mischief under $5,000 is the most common variant.
Quick Answer — Caledon
Point Duty defends mischief charges under Criminal Code s.430 — damaging property, rendering it useless, or interfering with someone's lawful use of it. Summary conviction where the damage is under $5,000 carries up to two years less a day, plus fines, probation, restitution, and a criminal record. A licensed paralegal can act on summary mischief.
On a Caledon mischief the fastest route to a sensible outcome is usually the most obvious one: get the damage repaired or replaced, and deal with it directly. The Crown at Orangeville generally wants to see that done before discussing how the charge should end, and in a community where the complainant is likely to be a neighbour, the repair matters to them more than the prosecution does. Point Duty Traffic Court Defence and Legal Services works Caledon mischief files in that order.
Damage to or interference with property — graffiti, vandalism, obstruction. Available defences turn on intent, ownership, and proportionality.
Mischief under s.430 covers wilful destruction, damage, rendering useless, or obstruction of the lawful use of property. Mischief under $5,000 is the most common variant.
| Crown's choice | Hybrid: the Crown chooses summary conviction or indictment |
|---|---|
| On summary conviction | Up to 2 years less a day in jail and/or a fine of up to $5,000 |
| On indictment | Up to 2 years for property worth $5,000 or less; up to 10 years for property worth more |
| Criminal record | Yes, on conviction |
| Other orders | Probation, and an order to pay for the damage |
| How it often resolves | Often withdrawn once restitution is paid, depending on the damage, sometimes with a common law peace bond. If a withdrawal is not available, an absolute or conditional discharge with probation is usually the next step. |
| Can a paralegal defend it? | Yes, once the Crown elects summary conviction |
Hybrid. On summary: up to 2 years less a day and/or a fine of up to $5,000. On indictment: up to 2 years where the property is worth $5,000 or less, and up to 10 years where it is worth more. Criminal record on conviction.
Disclosure review, restitution discussions, Crown resolution, peace bond, or trial.
Caledon traffic and Provincial Offences Act matters from Caledon OPP and the Town of Caledon bylaw are heard at the Caledon POA Court on Old Church Road. Criminal matters from Caledon proceed at the Orangeville Courthouse on Louisa Street.
10 Louisa Street, Orangeville, ON L9W 3P9
(519) 941-5802
Criminal matters from Caledon and Dufferin County.
Local practice notes reviewed 2026-09-11
Twenty minutes, confidential, no obligation. We’ll discuss your charge, the realistic outcomes, and the cost of defence before you commit to anything.